The eighth episode dives into Joanne’s obsession with the box of memories Noah has kept from his ex, Rebecca. After a week of fixation, she confronts Noah, who explains that he’s kept the box out of guilt but agrees to return it to Rebecca, seemingly resolving the issue.
Meanwhile, Noah is offered a promotion to Head Rabbi by Cohen, but there’s a catch—he must break up with Joanne. As he wrestles with this decision, Joanne and Morgan dig into the Rebecca box, echoing the behavior that led to Noah’s previous breakup with Rebecca.
Noah hands over the box to Rebecca before a double date with Sasha and Joanne. While the night goes well, Morgan stirs trouble by recording a conversation with Rebecca and sending it to Joanne, causing tension. Joanne accuses Noah of keeping secrets, but he offers to let her check his phone to prove his loyalty.
Realizing that Morgan is a toxic influence, Joanne confronts her, leading to a heated argument. Morgan calls Joanne “pathetic” for being happy, straining their friendship. The episode ends with Noah asking Joanne if she would ever consider converting to Judaism, casting uncertainty over their relationship.
This episode brings more drama, but some conflicts feel contrived, particularly around the Rebecca box. Joanne’s invasion of privacy mirrors what caused Noah’s last breakup, yet it’s conveniently overlooked. Morgan’s toxic role finally comes to light, but this reveal feels delayed.
While Noah’s career dilemma adds tension, the pacing remains uneven. The ongoing neglect of the podcast subplot is frustrating, leaving key storylines unresolved. With only a few episodes left, the show needs a stronger narrative push.
