Tom Hanks Reflects on Film Criticism and Superhero Fatigue, Calls for Fresh Storytelling
The Oscar-winning actor opens up about changing perceptions in film criticism and the evolving demands of audiences for original stories beyond the superhero genre.
Tom Hanks recently shared candid thoughts on movie criticism and evolving audience tastes during an appearance on Conan O’Brien Needs a Friend. While reminiscing about his 1996 directorial debut That Thing You Do!, Hanks recalled an initial negative review that he feels shifted over time. In a lighthearted yet fiery moment, he referred to critics with a humorous, expletive-laden remark, sparking laughter from O’Brien.
Hanks explained that one critic who dismissed That Thing You Do! as having a TV-like quality later praised the film as a cult classic, underscoring how time can alter perceptions. “All you need is 20 years,” Hanks quipped, hinting that a film’s impact often grows with its legacy.
While he acknowledges that poor reviews are part of the profession, Hanks embraces the idea that a film’s value can mature with time. “That’s the carnival, that’s the contest,” he said, describing the inherent unpredictability of how movies are received.
In a separate discussion on the Happy Sad Confused podcast, Hanks also commented on the rising phenomenon of superhero fatigue, pointing out that audiences are now seeking stories with fresh perspectives. Hanks recalled a period when superhero films felt personally resonant, making viewers feel like heroes themselves. “I feel like an X-Man sometimes. I am as confused as Spider-Man. I am as angry as Batman,” he joked, but admitted that even his own interest has evolved.
Reflecting on nearly two decades of superhero dominance, Hanks suggested that audiences now want more than special effects—they want meaningful stories that speak to real-life themes. “The industry often says, ‘If it worked once, it’ll work again,’ but the audience is way ahead. They’re asking, ‘What’s next?’” Hanks believes this shift is pushing Hollywood into new territory, challenging filmmakers to explore deeper, more impactful narratives.
