Cristin Milioti Is Ready for The Penguin Season 2 — Even If Everyone Else Is Taking Their Time

The Emmy-winning actress says she’d return “in a heartbeat,” as behind-the-scenes discussions hint at a potential sequel to the hit DC series.

Cristin Milioti is fully on board for a second season of The Penguin, her critically acclaimed DC series on HBO. The Emmy-winning actress, who played Sofia Falcone, openly admits she’s “in no rush to move on” — and would eagerly reprise her role if given the chance. “Every time I’m asked about Season 2, I’m like, ‘Sign me up!’” she said while promoting her new Netflix animated film, In Your Dreams.

Milioti’s enthusiasm comes amidst mixed feelings within the cast and creators. Colin Farrell, who stars as Oswald Cobblepot/The Penguin, has remained cautious about returning. Speaking at the SAG Awards earlier this year, he shared that he doesn’t feel a burning need for another season, explaining, “We all left it in the ring in those eight hours. I don’t want it, but I don’t not want it either.”

Despite the measured tone from some corners, executive producers Matt Reeves and Lauren LeFranc have confirmed that they’ve had discussions about a potential second season. However, any development might have to wait. Reeves is currently busy directing The Batman Part II, set to release in 2026, which could influence the direction of The Penguin if it moves forward.

One thing is certain: Milioti won’t be making an appearance in the new Batman film. Reeves explained that while her character made a major impact in The Penguin, she doesn’t organically fit into the current story arc for The Batman Part II. Still, he hinted that Sofia Falcone’s story might continue in future DC projects.

In the meantime, Milioti can be heard in Netflix’s new animated feature In Your Dreams, released on November 14, 2025. The film follows two siblings who travel into a dream world to meet the mythical Sandman, hoping he’ll help stop their parents’ divorce. Milioti voices the role of the mother, alongside Simu Liu as the father. Directed by Alex Woo in his feature debut, the film combines fantasy with emotional depth, offering children a relatable entry point into tough family changes.

Reflecting on the project, Milioti said she was drawn to the story’s emotional honesty: “The script conveys how we navigate big changes. This can feel like your world is falling apart — but it’s not as scary as it might seem.”

Why It Matters:

Milioti’s passion for a second season reflects the enthusiasm of fans, even as studio plans remain fluid.

The ongoing discussions between Reeves and LeFranc show that The Penguin may not be a one-and-done series after all.

Milioti’s continued success across mediums — from DC dramas to animated fantasy films — highlights her versatility and growing star power in Hollywood.