Episode 5 kicks off with Rusty attacking Brian Ratzer, causing a rift with Barbara, who is furious at his impulsive violence. Meanwhile, Eugenia confronts Tommy Molto about her role as a witness, vehemently denying any inappropriate relationship with Rusty. Raymond experiences a disturbing nightmare, fueling his anxiety about the case.
Rusty tails Brian Ratzer, leading to a tense encounter where Rusty tries to talk but fails. He later tries to convince Raymond and Mya that Liam Reynolds might be behind Carolyn’s murder, though they are skeptical. At home, Jaden questions Barbara about Rusty’s innocence, and Barbara reassures her daughter but privately admits her fears to Rusty.
Tommy reminisces about Carolyn preferring to work with Rusty, which he took personally. In the present, Nico asks Tommy about the Liam Reynolds angle, which Tommy dismisses. Barbara, after a drink, impulsively calls Clifton and ends up meeting him, leading to a romantic moment.
Brian Ratzer visits Rusty and his team, revealing he hires prostitutes and vaguely recognizing Bunny Davis. Meanwhile, Tommy makes a public statement, stirring controversy but hoping to sway the jury. The next morning, Rusty finds Kyle’s bike in the trash, showing his fatherly concern by taking it with him.
Barbara confides in her therapist about her kiss with Clifton, admitting it made her feel desired. Raymond suggests putting Barbara on the stand, but Rusty hesitates. The episode ends with the trial’s opening, Tommy’s emotional speech setting a powerful tone as Rusty realizes the prosecution’s strength.
This episode masterfully builds tension and deepens character dynamics. Rusty’s impulsive behavior and Barbara’s secret affair add layers of complexity to their relationship. The episode explores Rusty’s paranoia and desperation, emphasizing his vulnerability.
Tommy Molto’s character is fleshed out further, revealing his insecurities and personal vendetta against Rusty. His public statement and passionate courtroom speech highlight his cunning, aiming to manipulate the jury’s emotions. These moments add depth to his character, making him more than just a typical antagonist.
Barbara’s confession about her kiss with Clifton is a standout moment, offering insight into her emotional state. Ruth Negga’s performance shines as she navigates the delicate balance between loyalty to Rusty and her own need for validation. Her relationship with Jaden also adds an intriguing dynamic, reflecting the family’s internal struggles.
The episode’s pacing is steady, balancing courtroom drama with personal conflicts. While some plot points, like Brian Ratzer’s involvement, feel repetitive, the focus on character development keeps us engaged. The trial’s commencement promises intense drama ahead, with Rusty’s fate hanging in the balance.
